$175–225

The 11-room St. John Inn (Enighed, 340/693-8688, U.S. toll-free 800/666-7688, fax 340/693-9900, www.stjohninn.com [1], $160–205 winter, $100–140 summer) is another choice for travelers with more modest budgets. Rooms have air-conditioning, cable TV, phone, refrigerator, coffeemaker, and microwave, plus unique personalities with colorful decor and furnishings. Guests can also use the inn’s outdoor grill or relax around its teeny pool. The inn overlooks Enighed Pond and it’s about a five-minute walk to downtown Cruz Bay [2].