It isn’t tough deciding where to spend your cash on Cuttyhunk ; there simply aren’t many options. The best bets for souvenirs of any kind are the General Store (Broadway and Post Office Way), one of the only spots in town to find a deli and snacks, and film and pottery; and the Cuttyhunk Corner Store (at the Four Corners, 508/984-7167, 10 a.m.–5 p.m. Mon.–Sat.; 12 p.m.–5 p.m. Sun.) for handmade jewelry, pottery, clothing, and beach bags).
You may feel more inclined to look than buy at the contemporary Pea in Your Pants Gallery (Bayview Dr., 603/321-6326,hours vary; call ahead), but its makeshift gallery-in-a-barn is worth a look, for certain.