Cuba & Costa Rica Blog

Romney campaign calls for curtailing travel to Cuba

printer iconPrintemail iconEmailfavorites iconSave to Favorites
CUBA_4175 National Geographic Expeditions people-to-people educational exchange group, Trinidad de Cuba; copyright Christopher P. Baker.JPG

This being election year it seems timely to turn my attention to where President Obama versus Mitt Romney stand on the issue of Cuba relations, and specifically how it potentially affects you and I.

As regular readers of my blog know, President Obama has shown his support for the constitutional (and moral) right of U.S. citizens to travel freely without government interference.

To that end, he eliminated the Bush-era restrictions on travel to Cuba by Cuban-Americans, who were previously limited to one trip every three years (and then only to visit immediate nuclear family), without exception. Now they can travel to visit family on the island whenever and as often as they wish without asking for Uncle Sam’s “yay.”

And last year every U.S. citizen was guaranteed the right to visit Cuba to see and gauge things for themselves, ostensibly as “ambassadors of democracy,” when President Obama reinstated the Clinton-era “people to people” license category for group travel.

As the most recent Center for Democracy in the Americas (CDA) Cuba Central Newsblast makes clear, the Republican Party platform on Cuba couldn’t stand in starker contrast.

Here’s a pertinent extract of what the Romney campaign had to say about its Cuba plank last week:

"We reject any dynastic succession of power within the Castro family and affirm the principles codified in U.S. law as conditions for the lifting of trade, travel, and financial sanctions: the legalization of political parties, an independent media, and free and fair internationally-supervised elections."

As a report in the August 20, 2012, The Los Angeles Times states: “Cuban Americans can relax. The 2012 Republican platform will continue the party’s hard-line rhetoric toward the Communist regime in Cuba.”

Much of the platform calls for extending, or toughening, the failed five-decades-old embargo, including giving more teeth to such boondoogles as Radio and TV Martí

While the platform doesn’t explicitly call for reversing President Obama's travel reforms, Mitt Romney’s ten-point campaign plan for Cuba, issued on January 25, 2012, does indeed explicitly call for "Reinstating Travel & Remittance Restrictions."

Here are the relevant sections:

"Mitt Romney will adopt a clear policy toward the Cuban regime: no accommodation, no appeasement.... Unfortunately, President Obama has adopted a strategy of appeasement toward the Castro regime. He unilaterally relaxed sanctions without making any demands of the regime…. Now, increased travel and remittances to Cuba prop up a regime desperate for foreign currency." and "Mitt Romney will break sharply with President Obama’s appeasement strategy…. Mitt Romney’s policy toward Cuba will include… Reinstating Travel & Remittance Restrictions"

So there you have it!

Romney has stated he will revoke the people-to-people travel licenses and prevent Cuban-Americans from sending money to their hard-up families. All in the fantasy belief that this will hurt the Castro regime and help lead to its demise.

No consideration of stomping on U.S. citizens constitutional rights to travel. (It seems hypocritical, to say the least, that restricting freedoms of U.S. citizens somehow enhances the cause of promoting greater freedoms in Cuba.)

And no consideration that such Big Brother restrictions run counter to the Republican Party’s platform for less government intrusion in U.S. people’s lives.

Meanwhile, during a speech Romney gave on January 25, 2012, in Miami, here’s what he said while pandering to the Cuban-American crowd:

”This president has decided to give a gift, to Castro, to allow remittances to come from the United States to go into Cuba and help the economy of Cuba. He’s allowed more traveling into Cuba. Showing that olive branch if you will… If I’m President of the United States, we will return to Helms-Burton and the law, and we will not give Castro any gifts."

Part of the right-wing rallying cry against Cuba’s Communist government is a call for self-employment in Cuba, which the Raúl Castro government is now permitting, albeit in fits and starts.

How ironic then, or (again) hypocritical, that by attempting to throttle travel and tourism to Cuba, the Romney camp would deny Cuba’s budding self-employed entrepreneurs the very market they need to thrive. The self-employed sector relies on tourists and/or those Cubans with hard-currency remittances to spend. How absurd can Romney and the Republicans get?

Reason enough to vote for Obama.

Now that you’re ready to travel to Cuba, buy Moon Handbook Cuba

For further information on Havana, buy Moon Spotlight Havana.

Learn more about Christopher P. Baker.

Disclosure: I occasionally accept free or discounted travel when it coincides with my editorial goals. However, my opinion is never for sale. The opinions you see in Cuba & Costa Rica Journal are my unbiased reflection of the good, the bad, and the ugly

Copyright © Christopher P. Baker

Three petitions to save travel

Posted by jmcauliff on August 30, 2012 at 12:08 pm

Insight Cuba has addressed its own situation, and the impact on its staff
https://www.change.org/petitions/save-legal-travel-to-cuba?utm_source=IC...

LAWG takes a somewhat broader approach to people to people licensing
http://www.lawg.org/action-center/78-end-the-travel-ban-on-cuba/1064-wha...

FRD is raising the standard of a general license for all purposeful travel and opening up to all travel agents and tour operators.
http://signon.org/sign/remove-bureaucratic-obstacle?source=c.em.cp&r_by=...

Please sign and circulate whichever you like best -- or all three.

Critical Support for Obama

Posted by jmcauliff on August 27, 2012 at 9:08 am

While there is no question that President Obama has done major good with Cuban Americans (freedom of travel and remittances), he has taken only limited steps for the rest of us.

His policy is still premised on the goal of regime change (exporting our view of democracy), in contrast with US policy towards China, Vietnam, Saudi Arabia, etc. where our aspirations for greater freedom do not compromise a realistic normal diplomatic, economic and cultural relationship.

Implementation of purposeful travel has been left in the hands of the Office of Foreign Assets Control, headed by Adam Szubin, a Bush appointee, who seems more responsive to Cuban American Republicans than the White House.

As a result OFAC is requiring people to people licensees to overcome a bureaucratic obstacle course to obtain renewal of their licenses. Leading providers like Insight Cuba and National Geographic are caught in business destroying limbo. http://www.freep.com/article/20120822/COL21/120822010/Elen-Creager-Is-th...

There is no question that Obama is far superior to Romney, but he must be challenged during campaign appearances to do better.

All purposeful travel must receive a general license like that given to Cuban Americans, universities and religious organizations. That will remove OFAC from the process and permit non tourist travelers to either use guided tour groups or go on their own at lower cost, able to rent cars, use public transportation and stay in privately owned bed and breakfasts.

It will also enable third party providers of educational exchange to undertake programs and Americans to freely participate in and organize conferences in Cuba.

The time has long passed for the Cuban American National Foundation to be Obama's principal link to south Florida.

John McAuliff
Fund for Reconciliation and Development

Buy Moon Travel Guides

Loading books
loading
For more Moon travel information, sign up for our monthly e-newsletter for updates on new travel guide releases, travel tips and trip ideas for those seeking adventure or relaxation, and expert advice from our on-the-go Moon travel authors.

Find Activities>>

Moon Travel Guides make independent travel and outdoor exploration fun and accessible. With expert and adventurous travel writers delivering a mix of honest insight, first-rate strategic travel advice, insider travel tips and an essential dose of humor, Moon Travel Guides ensure that travelers have an uncommon and entirely satisfying experience. Each travel book is filled with unique trip ideas, easy-to-use maps, and detailed information on sights, restaurants, and accommodations. Moon Travel Guides not only point you in the right direction, they inspire new ideas and adventure. Whether you are seeking a relaxing beach trip to Hawaii, or an adventure travel trip to the rainforests of Costa Rica, Moon guidebooks—and Moon.com—are with you every step of the way. Founded in 1973, the Moon Travel Guides series includes Moon Handbooks, Moon Outdoors, Moon Metro, Moon Living Abroad and Moon Spotlight travel books. Moon is based in Berkeley, California and is a proud member of the Perseus Books Group.