Brazil Blog

Bahia's Police Strike

printer iconPrintemail iconEmailfavorites iconSave to Favorites

I’ve never lived in a place in which the U.S. Embassy put out an Emergency Travel Alert to steer clear of it. However, last week my adopted hometown of Salvador became such a place.

As a result of a state-wide strike of Bahia’s military police that began on February 1, Salvador was prey to random looting, blocked highways, soaring homicide levels, and a sudden and general malaise among the population that oscillated between subtle tension and full-blown panic. Fearful of looting and arrastões (swarming, i.e. assaults by large groups of youths), stores closed early and the streets were eerily deserted at night. Classes for school children (scheduled to start on February 6 after a long summer break) were cancelled as were dozens of cultural events including many rehearsals held by the city’s biggest Carnaval blocos and musical artists.

In fact, the biggest fear of all was what would happen next week when Carnaval festivities are scheduled to begin. Salvador’s Carnaval – which lasts for 7 bacchanalian days and nights – is the longest and largest street party on the planet. It is also the city’s single biggest money-maker, responsible for lining the pockets of everyone from musicians, producers, hotel and restaurant owners and taxi drivers to beer vendors, who spend nights weaving through the crowds with Styrofoam coolers on their shoulders (and days sleeping on sidewalks in improvised cardboard box houses), and catadores de latas, who earn months of income from a week of salvaging crumpled aluminum beer cans and selling them to recycling plants.

One of the Military Police’s frequent chants was “Cancelar o Carnaval” Although Bahia’s state governor vowed such a travesty would never occur (it would be tantamount to canceling Christmas), the crucial timing of the strike – certainly no coincidence – really upped the stakes, not to mention the tension as tourists from all over Brazil and overseas began cancelling their trips en masse.

In Brazil, there are three main police forces: the Polícia Militar (PM), the Polícia Civil, and the Polícia Federal. While the federal and civil police deal with investigations and crimes on a national and local (state) level, respectively, the military police (under the aegis of the Security Secretary of each state) is responsible for maintaining safety and order and actually policing the streets.

Viewed the fact that on any given day, safety and order in Salvador – and most Brazilian cities – is precarious (in Salvador, it’s not uncommon to hear of a weekend murder rate in which there were 50-something casualties, the majority of them drug-related), it’s hardly surprising that the sudden absence of PMs in the streets left many Bahians imagining the worst. Such projections were hardly helped by TV and newspaper coverage, which tended toward the sensationalistic with headlines that screamed “It’s War!,” and online features such as a “Map of Chaos”, which used bold graphics to indicate hot spots for bus assaults, murders, looting, etc.

With the aim of quelling such fears, President Dilma Rousseff sent 3,500 army troops to maintain order throughout the state. It was somehow both reassuring, and not, to see jeeps full of soldiers decked out in rifles and camouflage garb patrolling the eerily quiet streets. Meanwhile, no sooner had federal forces arrived when striking PMs – accompanied by their wives and children – invaded the state legislative assembly building. After fencing them in, the Army surrounded the buildings, which for a few days, became the scene of an increasingly tense face-off between the forces of order.

The relationship that Brazilians have with both the government figures and police is a highly ambiguous one. On one level, the PMs enjoy some support from the population. Despite the fact that Brazilians hardly view police as benevolent symbols of order (there are far too many corrupt and/or violent cops), they tend to sympathize with the fact that police are woefully underpaid, especially viewed the life-and-death situations with which they are increasingly confronted as a result of the escalation of the urban drug trade.

However, earlier this week, recordings of the military police commander came to light (and were broadcast on the national news), which revealed that at least some police were involved in deliberately burning cars, blocking highways, and wreaking other havoc in order to spread panic and put pressure on the government to meet their demands for increased salaries, “gratifications” and amnesty to all strikers. Once proof of what some already suspected became concrete and went viral, the PM’s strike stance became increasingly unsustainable, especially with the onset of Carnaval.

As such, it wasn’t that surprising that late last night, with only 4 days left before the first Carnaval activities kick off on Thursday, the strike came to an end; so that “the population wouldn’t suffer” any more. At the same time, a similar strike in Rio de Janeiro – not just of military police, but of civil police and firefighters as well – was suspended.

Recent events certainly say a lot about the power of government and security forces, of criminals, of the media, and of ordinary citizens in Brazil. They also really underscore the power of Carnaval. Next week, Salvador will erupt into its usual 7-day frenzy of unbridled and escapist hedonism, allowing people to momentarily dance their troubles away. When it’s all over, the usual “hangover”, promises to be more serious than usual.

Bahia's Police Strike

Posted by marichi on February 20, 2012 at 8:02 am

Oi Michael

I had just been reading about the chaos of the past couple of weeks and hoping it's died down considerably for Carnaval? Did you ever feel NOT safe while living there, while in the midst of it? I always seem to think that reporting is worse than the situation actually is, but when I hear of murders doubling in numbers, I second-guess the actual safety. Would love to still recommend Salvador as a city to visit as it had been one of my favorite stops, but crime is always an issue...

Enjoy the week, I hope it's all fun regardless!

Best regards,
Marissa

Oi Marissa, Great to hear

Posted by MSommers on March 1, 2012 at 3:03 am

Oi Marissa,

Great to hear from you.

As was expected, the Military Police strike was resolved before Carnaval (it would have been Unthinkable for it not to have been) and Salvador's mega street party apparently went off without a hitch (I only joined the festivities on Friday night before hightailing it out of town to escape the rest).

During the strike, nobody went out much at night; many bars were closed and a lot of events were cancelled. It wasn't so much that bad things were occurring (although the press, prone to sensationalism, bandied around the inflated homicide rate - much of which, however, was seemingly drug trade-related), but that people were afraid of what could potentially occur. At any rate, the streets were eerie and deserted at night (although refreshingly uncluttered by day) so people stayed at home after dusk; a VERY difficult predicament for Bahians during the height of summer, days before Carnaval.

I can't say that I felt "NOT safe" living here during that time. Although the police were on strike, Dilma had sent in army troops so it wasn't as if there was no "order". Like others, I mostly stayed home (although I did go out a couple of nights) because it was the thing to do and there was a strange atmosphere of nervous tension in the air. Living in a large Brazilian city, one does become accustomed to not courting danger - and since potential dangers are higher, one tends to live more "on the defensive" in general.

I think the strike tapped into general, underlying fears for safety that that the population in Salvador - and other cities - live with on a constant basis - it brought these fears to the fore.

That said, I think the situation for tourists visiting Salvador is somewhat different. While tourists SHOULD take precautions and definitely be aware of the risks of being pickpocketed/robbed in many places, a lot of the serious violent crimes take place in more peripheral neighborhoods (where tourists wouldn't/shouldn't be) and is drug-related (which isn't to minimalize the homicide rates - which are staggering).

Thanks for reading/following.

Abraços to you and Lulu,

Michael

Buy Moon Travel Guides

Loading books
loading
For more Moon travel information, sign up for our monthly e-newsletter for updates on new travel guide releases, travel tips and trip ideas for those seeking adventure or relaxation, and expert advice from our on-the-go Moon travel authors.

Find Activities>>

Moon Travel Guides make independent travel and outdoor exploration fun and accessible. With expert and adventurous travel writers delivering a mix of honest insight, first-rate strategic travel advice, insider travel tips and an essential dose of humor, Moon Travel Guides ensure that travelers have an uncommon and entirely satisfying experience. Each travel book is filled with unique trip ideas, easy-to-use maps, and detailed information on sights, restaurants, and accommodations. Moon Travel Guides not only point you in the right direction, they inspire new ideas and adventure. Whether you are seeking a relaxing beach trip to Hawaii, or an adventure travel trip to the rainforests of Costa Rica, Moon guidebooks—and Moon.com—are with you every step of the way. Founded in 1973, the Moon Travel Guides series includes Moon Handbooks, Moon Outdoors, Moon Metro, Moon Living Abroad and Moon Spotlight travel books. Moon is based in Berkeley, California and is a proud member of the Perseus Books Group.